Because one answer becomes the number your client measures everything against, and the facts are usually still coming in.
Your client is scared and wants to know how this ends. That is a fair thing to want. "What am I going to get?" deserves a real reply. Even so, one number may not be the best reply. If the final result comes in lower, your client may feel that you promised something and did not deliver. That is also the client who starts questioning your bill.
Scenarios give your client a real choice. They also let you change your view when the facts change.
What Is A Scenario?
A scenario is a whole settlement, with every piece filled in. "What if she keeps the house?" is only a question. A scenario shows what keeping the house does to everything else.
For example, let’s say that a couple has $200,000 of equity in a house and $300,000 in his 401(k). Below are three scenarios that you could put in front of them:
- Keep The House – She keeps the house and refinances it in her own name. He keeps $250,000 of the 401(k) and she receives $50,000 of it.
- Sell Now – They sell the house and split what is left after selling costs. They split the 401(k) evenly, at $150,000 each.
- Sell Later – She stays in the house for two years with the children, and then they sell. They split the 401(k) evenly, and they decide now who pays what until the sale.
The first one looks even on paper at $250,000 each. It is not the same $250,000, though. His share is all pre-tax money, and hers is mostly equity in a house she has to keep paying for. A client who only asked for the house can now see what the house costs.
How Many Should You Build?
One option is to build three. One looks like your recommendation in disguise. Ten will confuse everybody.
Build them around what the two people actually disagree about. If nobody is fighting over the car, do not make the car a variable. Keep everything else the same from one scenario to the next, so the comparison is fair.
Below is what can be shown for each scenario:
- The Terms – Who gets what and who pays what, in plain words.
- The Monthly Budget – What each person’s monthly picture looks like afterward.
- The Tax Treatment – Which dollars are pre-tax, and which have a low basis.
- The Assumptions – Every assumption, labeled, including the dates and rates you used.
- The Next Steps – What has to happen next, such as a refinance or a QDRO.
Some things are not scenarios. A filing deadline or a plan rule is a fact, so tell your client that directly. And if a scenario plainly does not work, say so. If she cannot qualify for the refinance, do not leave Keep The House on the table to be polite.
Put The Date In The Scenario
Timing changes what a settlement is worth, and clients rarely think of it as something they can choose.
Below are some examples of why the date matters:
- Year End – Marital status for federal tax is decided on the last day of the tax year. Run the numbers on both sides of December 31 if the date is still open.
- Ten Years – A former spouse generally needs a marriage that lasted at least 10 years to claim on the other’s Social Security record. If a couple is at nine years and ten months, somebody should notice.
- Vesting – Stock awards and pensions have their own dates. Show what changes if the marriage ends before or after the next one.
- Valuation Date – States differ on the date used to value assets. Find out what your state allows before you run the numbers.
A Note For Lawyers
Your client decides whether to settle. State versions of Rule 1.2 and Rule 1.4 of the professional conduct rules generally say so, and they require you to explain things well enough for the client to make that decision. Read your own state’s version.
Scenarios do not get you out of giving an opinion. Rule 2.1 calls for candid advice, and your client is paying for your judgment. A professional might say something like this. "Here are three possible paths. Based on what is known today, the second one appears most likely. Here is what would change that view."
If you use BATNA, use it correctly. It means your best alternative to a negotiated agreement, or what you can expect if the talks fail. It comes from Getting to Yes. It is a different thing from the best result at trial. WATNA is the worst alternative. For a divorce client, the alternative might be trial, or it might be months more of negotiating and paying for it. Put a cost on it.
Then rerun the scenarios when something changes. After discovery comes in or the other side moves, tell your client what changed and what did not.
A Note For Mediators
When someone turns to you and asks "What do you think is fair?", do not answer that question. The Model Standards of Conduct for Mediators make party self-determination the first standard. They also say that mixing the mediator’s role with another profession is a problem.
That does not mean you have to stay silent. The 2025 Model Standards for Family and Divorce Mediation say that you may give information you are qualified to give, if it fits with impartiality and self-determination. They also say that you shall not give therapy or legal advice. Some programs and states draw this line differently, so check yours.
So one option is to offer scenarios and let the parties do the choosing. Make sure each person can find at least one scenario they could live with, so nobody feels steered. Use caucus to ask what would have to change for a "no" to become a "maybe". Do not carry that answer to the other room without consent.
A Note For Financial Advisors And Neutrals
If you hand over one number, the assumptions disappear inside it. Then each side goes hunting for the assumption that gets them a better number, and you end up defending your math instead of explaining a choice.
Label every assumption on the page. Use the same format and the same depth for each scenario. Do not call one "recommended" unless your engagement letter says that recommending is your job.
You can still say what the numbers show. If a proposal does not cash flow, tell both of them so. That is a finding about the math. What they should agree to is their call, and their lawyers can advise them on it.
A Note For Coaches
Your client will ask "Am I going to be okay?" You do not know, and you should not guess. Build the scenarios around readiness instead.
Ask about each possible outcome, including the good one. "If this is what happens, what do you do in the first week?" Rehearsing only the worst case can send a client into a negotiation ready for a fight.
Stay in your lane. Legal and financial results belong to the lawyer and the financial neutral. "Will I get the house?" is often also "Can I afford the house?", and neither one is yours to answer. If you are ICF credentialed, its code of ethics asks you to work within your competency. Send your client to the right person, and check what your state says about the unauthorized practice of law.
Try It On One Open Matter
Pick one open matter where your client keeps asking for a number. Write down the one issue that is really in dispute, and build three scenarios around it before your next meeting. Put your assumptions on the page, and ask your client which one they would like to talk through first.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related:
- Should your client keep the house or sell it?
- How do you work with clients who weigh money decisions differently?
- When should a divorce team include a coach?
- How does divorce change Social Security benefits?