Divorce does not divide Social Security. Each person keeps their own record, and neither one can be awarded part of the other’s benefit.
What divorce can change is who may claim on whose record. If the marriage lasted at least 10 years, your client may be able to collect on the ex’s record, both while the ex is alive and after the ex dies. If the marriage lasted less than 10 years, that door is generally closed.
That makes the date on the decree one of the more expensive dates in the file.
Check the 10-year date first
The 10 years must be complete before the divorce becomes final. Separation does not stop the clock, and neither does filing. The decree date is what counts.
For example, let’s say that your client married in June 2017. She has a small work record, and her husband earned far more. If the decree is entered in May 2027, she falls about a month short. If it is entered in July 2027, she may have a claim on his record for the rest of her life.
One option is to put the marriage date and the anniversary on the first page of every intake. If a matter is close to 10 years, do not let the date get decided by the court calendar. Raise it with your client and let someone make the decision on purpose. The other side may have reasons for hurrying, but a claim on his record costs him nothing, as you will see below.
Know what the divorced spouse benefit pays
Below are the rules for claiming on a living ex’s record:
- Age – Your client must be at least 62.
- Marital status – Your client must be unmarried. A later marriage blocks the claim unless that marriage has ended.
- The ex’s status – The ex must be entitled to retirement or disability benefits. If the couple has been divorced for at least two continuous years, the ex only needs to be at least 62 and fully insured. The ex does not need to have filed.
- Own record – If your client’s own benefit at full retirement age is at least half of the ex’s, there is no extra payment.
- Amount – The most it pays is half of the ex’s full retirement age amount.
- Early claim – For someone with a full retirement age of 67, claiming at 62 cuts that half down to 32.5 percent of the ex’s amount.
Two more points are worth saying plainly. Waiting past full retirement age does not raise a divorced spouse benefit. Delayed retirement credits raise the worker’s own check, not the former spouse’s. Also, your client generally cannot take the spouse benefit now and let her own benefit grow. Filing early for one is treated as filing for the other.
Tell the client what it does not cost the ex
A divorced spouse claim does not lower the ex’s benefit. It does not lower what a new spouse gets either. The family maximum does not apply to it, and other family members on that record are figured as if the divorced spouse were not there.
Say this out loud in mediation. A client may assume that the ex’s claim comes out of their own check, and then fight over something that is not at stake.
Plan for the ex’s death
This is the bigger number, and it may deserve the most time. A surviving divorced spouse can receive as much as the ex’s full benefit, not half.
Below are the rules to check:
- Age – Your client must generally be at least 60, or at least 50 with a qualifying disability.
- Amount – The benefit runs from 71.5 percent at the earliest age up to 100 percent at survivor full retirement age.
- Delayed credits – Credits the ex earned by waiting count toward the survivor amount, unlike the spouse benefit.
- Remarriage – A remarriage after age 60 does not block the claim. An earlier remarriage generally does while that marriage lasts. The disability rules are different.
- Young children – A divorced parent caring for the ex’s child under 16 or disabled child may qualify for a mother’s or father’s benefit. That benefit has no 10-year requirement.
For a client who is close to retirement, this changes the conversation about remarriage. Marrying at 59 and marrying at 61 can have very different results.
The rule on deemed filing names retirement and spouse benefits, not survivor benefits. So a surviving divorced spouse may be able to take one benefit first and switch to the other later. Have your client ask Social Security to run both orders before she files.
Do not write a clause that divides the benefit
Federal law says that the right to future Social Security payments cannot be transferred or assigned. It also keeps those payments away from most legal process. There is an exception for child support and alimony. That exception specifically leaves out payments made to divide property.
Agreement by the parties may not save a clause like this. In Michigan, a consent judgment told a couple to equalize their Social Security benefits, and the Court of Appeals held the term preempted. In Washington, an agreed decree gave the wife half of the husband’s benefits, and the Court of Appeals held that part of the order void. It sent the whole property division back to the trial court, more than a decade after the decree.
A formula may not be a reliable way to draft around this. A clause that goes bad later can reopen the settlement or leave your client with nothing to enforce.
Check your state on offsets
States do not all treat Social Security the same way once it is out of the division itself. In the Washington case, the court said a judge may consider that a party will receive Social Security, but cannot divide the benefit. It also pointed to earlier authority that valuing the benefit and offsetting it against other property would be error. The U.S. Supreme Court rejected an offsetting award for Railroad Retirement benefits, under very similar language, in Hisquierdo v. Hisquierdo.
Do not assume that either approach applies where you practice. It may help to check your state’s appellate cases before you put a present value for Social Security into any settlement exhibit. If your state allows the judge to consider it, show the monthly estimates as a fact about each person’s future income, and say what you are using them for.
Rerun any old government pension numbers
The Social Security Fairness Act repealed the Government Pension Offset and the Windfall Elimination Provision, for benefits payable for months after December 2023. Before that, a teacher or firefighter with a pension from uncovered work could see a spouse or survivor benefit cut sharply or wiped out.
If your templates or your memory still carry those reductions, the projection will be wrong.
Look at Medicare too
Medicare entitlement at 65 is tied to being eligible for Social Security on a record, even if the person has not filed for the cash benefit. So a client with few work credits may be able to get premium-free Part A through a 10-year marriage. Confirm this with Social Security or Medicare.
Get the statements before you negotiate
Have both parties download their statements from their my Social Security accounts, and ask for the ex’s statement in discovery if it is not offered. Do not rely on a guess from your client about what the check will be. Put the marriage date, the planned decree date and each person’s full retirement age amount into your file, and take those numbers to the next session.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related:
- Who pays for long-term care after a late-life divorce?
- What happens to Medicaid planning when a couple divorces?
- Which retirement plans can a QDRO not divide?
- What is different about a high-net-worth divorce?