A QDRO is built for private employer plans covered by ERISA, such as most 401(k)s and company pensions. IRAs, federal and military retirement, railroad benefits and Social Security each follow other rules. State, local, church and nonqualified plans may also fall outside the QDRO rules, so you have to check the plan itself.

Calling an order a QDRO does not make it work. The plan or agency decides whether it will honor your paper. A rejected order means more drafting, more delay, and hours your client may question or refuse to pay for.

Check These Plans First

Below are the plans and what each one needs instead:

  • IRAs – These include traditional, Roth, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs. No QDRO is used. Under the tax code, a transfer under a divorce or separation instrument is not taxable, and the custodian will have its own paperwork.
  • Federal Civilian Pensions (FERS And CSRS) – OPM processes a court order that meets its own rule, 5 CFR Part 838. An order labeled a QDRO or issued on an ERISA form is not acceptable unless it expressly says Part 838 governs its FERS or CSRS terms.
  • Thrift Savings Plan – The TSP takes a retirement benefits court order under 5 CFR Part 1653. The order must expressly relate to the TSP account and either freeze the account or direct a payment of a dollar amount, a percentage or a survivor annuity.
  • Military Retired Pay – State courts can divide disposable retired pay under 10 U.S.C. 1408, and the Defense Department pays from that order. Direct payment has limits, which are covered below.
  • Railroad Retirement – Tier I cannot be divided at all. Tier II and supplemental annuities can be, under 45 U.S.C. 231m and the Railroad Retirement Board’s rules at 20 CFR Part 295. The Board says it will accept an order called a QDRO only if it makes a partition that is valid under those rules.
  • Social Security – No order can divide it. Federal law bars assigning future benefits. A former spouse’s benefit, if any, comes from Social Security’s own rules.
  • VA Disability Pay – State courts cannot treat it as divisible property, even when retired pay was waived to receive it.
  • State And Local Government Plans – ERISA does not cover them. Each system follows its own statute and procedures. Ohio’s public systems, for example, use a Division of Property Order under Ohio Revised Code 3105.80 to 3105.90.
  • Church Plans – These are outside ERISA unless the plan elected to be covered. Ask the plan what it requires, and in writing.
  • Nonqualified And Top-Hat Plans – ERISA’s QDRO section does not apply to these plans. Whether a former spouse can be paid directly depends on the plan terms and state law.
  • Plans Outside The United States – ERISA excludes plans kept outside the country mainly for nonresident aliens. A US order may not reach these at all. It may help to get local advice before promising your client anything.

Watch Military Pay Closely

Military pay has its own traps. Below are some of the ones that may be worth checking:

  • The 10-Year Overlap – The Defense Department pays a former spouse directly only if the marriage overlapped at least 10 years of creditable service. This limits direct payment. A court may still divide the pension in a shorter marriage, and your client then collects from the retiree.
  • The 50% Cap – Direct payments for property division cannot exceed 50% of disposable retired pay.
  • The Frozen Benefit – If the divorce is final before retirement, the divisible amount is generally based on pay at the date of the decree, plus cost-of-living increases.
  • A Disability Waiver – Under Mansell and Howell, a state court cannot divide retired pay waived for disability benefits. It also cannot order the veteran to make up the loss to the former spouse. Courts have split on whether a settlement promise to do so can be enforced, so check the current law.

If your client is the former spouse, do not treat a military pension share as certain income. Ask about disability status and what the settlement says if the pay shrinks.

Do Not Offset Around A Tier I Bar

Railroad Tier I deserves a second look. In Hisquierdo v. Hisquierdo, the Supreme Court held that community property law could not reach railroad benefits. It also rejected an offsetting award of other property. Congress later opened up Tier II and supplemental annuities, but Tier I stayed protected.

So do not draft an offset for Tier I without a lawyer looking at it closely. The same caution applies when someone wants to offset Social Security. State rules differ on what a court may consider.

Know Where QDRO Rules Still Touch

Some plans fall outside ERISA and still use QDRO rules for tax purposes. That is why this topic confuses people. Below are the main ones:

  • Governmental, Church And 457(b) Plans – The tax code treats a payment under a qualifying domestic relations order from these plans as made under a QDRO. That covers the tax result. It does not make the plan accept your form.
  • Owner-Only Plans – A solo 401(k) covering only an owner and spouse is outside ERISA Title I. It is still a tax-qualified plan, so one option is to use a QDRO anyway unless a tax professional says otherwise.
  • Non-ERISA 403(b) Plans – The code treats payments from a 403(b) under a QDRO much like payments from a qualified plan. Ask the provider what form it wants.
  • Nonqualified Plans – Rules under section 409A let a plan pay someone other than the employee, or pay early, to carry out a domestic relations order. The plan must still be willing to do it. Rev. Rul. 2002-22 taxes the former spouse on vested deferred compensation transferred in a divorce. It does not cover rights that are unvested at the transfer. These plans are unfunded, so your client also carries the employer’s credit risk.

Use The Right Tool For Each Account

For example, let’s say that a federal employee has a $400,000 TSP account, a FERS pension, a $100,000 401(k) from an old job and a $50,000 IRA. That one marriage needs four different pieces of paper. The TSP needs a retirement benefits court order, and FERS needs an order under Part 838. The 401(k) needs a QDRO, and the IRA needs a transfer through the custodian. One template will not do all four.

The tool also changes your client’s options later. A former spouse who takes cash from a 401(k) under a QDRO avoids the 10% early distribution penalty, though income tax still applies. That exception does not apply to IRAs. Your client may want to take any needed cash from the 401(k) before rolling the rest over. Check the rules before you rely on this for the TSP or another governmental plan.

Ask These Questions Before You Draft

Below are things that may be worth requesting for every account on the balance sheet:

  • What Kind Of Plan Is It – Get the plan document or summary plan description. A statement balance does not tell you this.
  • What Does The Plan Require – ERISA plans must have written QDRO procedures and must give them to the parties. Other plans and agencies have their own rules, so ask for those too.
  • Will It Review A Draft – Send a draft to anyone who will review one before the judge signs it.
  • What Happens At Death – Ask this for each plan. A former spouse’s share may stop when the employee dies unless survivor benefits are addressed. For federal pensions, the order must expressly award the survivor annuity.
  • What Protects The Money Until Then – An ERISA plan must segregate the disputed amount while it reviews an order, for up to 18 months. Other plans may have nothing like it, so ask about a freeze.

Start with a simple list of every retirement account, its plan type and the paper it needs. Do that before the settlement is signed, while there is still time to fix the language.

See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.

Related:

Bring VennBoard into your practice.

One workspace for cases, clients, and the professionals you work alongside — built for divorce professionals — including divorce financial coaches, mediators, attorneys, and adjacent practitioners.