Separate the facts from the preferences. Get one set of numbers that everyone trusts, then ask each client what they are trying to protect, and show the options in those terms.
Some fights about money in a divorce are really two fights. One is about what the numbers are. The other is about what the numbers should do. You can settle the first with documents. The second belongs to the clients.
Divorce is hard enough without feeling judged for how you think about a dollar. So do not judge. Do the math and be straight about what it says.
Expect The Difference
Couples often differ on money, and the difference can matter.
Rick, Small and Finkel studied spending attitudes in married people, with data pooled from 1,209 married consumers. Spouses tended to be opposites on a spendthrift to tightwad scale. Bigger differences went along with more arguments over finances, and those arguments went along with lower marital well-being. Those were survey results, and at least part of the sample was not random, so read them as associations.
Dew, Britt and Huston reported in 2012 that financial disagreements predicted divorce more strongly than other common disagreements. That is a prediction, and it does not prove the money fights caused the divorces.
Neither study looks at people negotiating a settlement. They support a modest point. If your two clients see money differently, that is ordinary, and it was probably there before the divorce. Do not expect them to agree on what a dollar is for, because they may never have agreed.
Do Not Guess From The Label
Do not assume how a client weighs risk from gender, age or job. The research on gender and risk is mixed. Filippin and Crosetto pooled 54 replications of one standard lab task, with about 7,000 people, and found differences that were significant but small. Eckel and Grossman read the experimental work as showing that women are usually more averse to risk, with less consistent results in studies that use real-world framing.
Lab tasks are not settlement talks, either way. So ask your client. It takes one question and it costs you nothing.
The same goes for quizzes. Published tools such as the Klontz Money Script Inventory are real research instruments, but the original 2011 paper used a convenience sample of 422 people. Handing one out in a joint session may not help, and neither may putting a label on anyone. If a client seems stuck on old beliefs about money, that is a job for someone with the right training.
Ask What They Are Protecting
Below are questions to consider asking each client, separately if you can:
- The Worst Case – What outcome would scare you most five years from now?
- The Monthly Number – What do you need coming in each month to feel all right? Then check it against the budget.
- Now Or Later – If you had to choose, would you take less today or less at 65?
- The Thing You Would Not Trade – What would you give up money to keep?
- The Past – How did the two of you make money decisions during the marriage, and who had the last word?
Write the answers down in the client’s own words. Use those words later when you explain a tradeoff.
Show The Same Numbers Two Ways
For example, let’s say that a couple has $200,000 in house equity and $200,000 in a traditional 401(k). She wants the house because the kids are in that school. He wants the 401(k) because he is scared of retiring broke. On paper, that looks like an even split.
It may not be. Money taken from a traditional 401(k) is generally taxable when it comes out, so that $200,000 is not the same as $200,000 of equity. The house has its own costs, which include the mortgage, insurance, taxes, repairs, and selling costs if she sells later. Whether the plan can be divided and how depends on the plan and your state’s rules, and she may need to refinance to get his name off the loan.
So one option is to show her one page on the monthly cost of the house against her income, for the next five years. For him, one option is one page on what the 401(k) may be worth at 65 after taxes, with a low and a high assumption. It is the same settlement on both pages, and each page answers the question that client asked.
Now they can argue about the real tradeoff. Maybe she decides the house is worth it for three years until the youngest finishes school. Maybe he accepts less retirement money for more cash now. Either one might be reasonable.
Show your assumptions every time. If you use a growth rate or a tax rate, say so on the page. When a client later asks why the number changed, you can point to the line. That also helps with hours your client questions, because they can see what you did and why.
Tell The Truth When The Math Fails
A preference is one thing. A plan that does not work is another.
If your client wants the house and the budget is short $800 a month, say so plainly. Show them the page. Then let them decide, and write down what you told them.
Below is one view of the limits for each role:
- Lawyers – Under Model Rule 1.2(a), the client decides whether to settle, and under Rule 1.4(b) you explain enough for an informed decision. State versions differ. Rule 2.1 calls for candid advice, and it lets you bring in economic and other non-legal considerations.
- Mediators – The 2025 Model Standards put self-determination first and say that a mediator should never pressure parties into settlement. They also say you may give information you are qualified to give, but not therapy or legal advice. Tell the parties to have an independent attorney review the agreement before it is signed.
- Financial Advisors And Neutrals – Show the consequences and be clear about your assumptions. If you are neutral, show both spouses the same analysis. Stay out of which spouse has the better values.
- Coaches – Help the client say what matters to them, and hand the math to whoever does the math.
Watch For Pressure
Some things that look like a preference are something else.
A client who says "I do not care, give him whatever he wants" may simply want it over. They may also be afraid. They may never have been allowed to see the accounts. The 2025 Model Standards ask mediators to look at financial pressure and abuse, including coercive control, separately and confidentially with each party. Lawyers and advisors should pay attention to the same thing.
Below are some signs that may deserve a closer look:
- One Voice – One spouse answers every money question for the other.
- Fast Agreement – The client agrees quickly to terms well below what they seem to be entitled to, and cannot tell you why.
- Fear Of The Reaction – The client asks what the other spouse will do when they see the proposal.
Do not diagnose anything, and do not raise it in a joint meeting. Talk to the client alone, and bring in people trained for abuse if that is what you are seeing.
Start With One Page
Pick the next matter where the two sides seem far apart. Before the next meeting, ask each client the five questions above. Then put the disputed option on one page per client, with the numbers and the assumptions showing. You will find out quickly whether the two sides disagree about facts or about what they want.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related: