The divorce law is the same. The timeline often is not, and that can change the money and the parenting plan.
Since Obergefell v. Hodges in 2015, states must allow and recognize same-sex marriages. The Supreme Court turned down a request to revisit that case in November 2025, although a denial is not a ruling on the merits. Federal law also bars denying full faith and credit to another state’s marriage records based on the spouses’ sex.
The real difference is history. Many couples built a life together for years before they could legally marry. Most of the law measures only the legal marriage, so a long relationship can look like a short one on paper.
Some of these clients waited a long time for this marriage. Be kind about that, then get the dates.
Write Down Every Date
Do not start with the marriage certificate alone. Build a timeline of the whole relationship, because different rules may use different dates.
Below are the dates to collect:
- Moving In – When the couple started living together and combining money.
- Formal Relationships – Any domestic partnership, civil union or foreign marriage, with the place and the date.
- Marriage – The place and date of each ceremony. Some couples have more than one.
- Assets – When each house, retirement account and business was acquired, and in whose name.
- Children – Each birth or adoption, and any court order or parentage document.
Also check whether any earlier partnership or civil union was ever dissolved. If a couple has both a partnership and a marriage, find out whether ending one ends the other. One option is to ask for that to be addressed in the same case.
Ask What Counts Before The Marriage
This is the main fight in many of these cases, and states do not agree. Do not tell your client what the answer will be until you have read your state’s cases.
Two state high courts show the range:
- New Hampshire – In Munson and Beal, the court said a trial court may consider premarital cohabitation in dividing property. It said this applies to all divorces, not just same-sex couples. The couple had lived together about 15 years before a civil union.
- Nevada – In Candelaria v. Kelly, the court required recognition of a 2008 California marriage. It declined to backdate the marriage to the date the couple would have married without Nevada’s unconstitutional ban.
For example, let’s say that a couple has been together for 22 years and married 8 years ago. One spouse has a $900,000 retirement account, and $700,000 of it was saved before the marriage. If only the marriage years count, the marital share may be about $200,000. If the court can consider the earlier years, the conversation looks very different. That is a big gap, and it should not be left to a default formula.
Do not stop at the divorce statute. Your client may have claims based on contract, an implied agreement or fairness, depending on the state. Some states also have their own rules for unmarried partners, such as Washington’s committed intimate relationship cases. Check the deadlines for these claims too.
Check Where State And Federal Law Split
A state may treat a domestic partner as a spouse while federal law does not. California gives registered partners the same state-law rights and duties as spouses. The federal tax regulations exclude registered partnerships and civil unions from the definition of marriage. The Department of Labor reads ERISA the same way.
That split matters at the end of a relationship. Below are some of the things to check:
- Property Transfers – The tax-free transfer rule in Section 1041 applies to spouses and former spouses. The IRS’s FAQ for registered partners does not address transfers at dissolution. For any years before the marriage, or a couple who never married, it may help to get a tax opinion and not assume the transfer is tax free.
- Retirement Plans – A qualified domestic relations order can name a spouse, former spouse, child or other dependent as an alternate payee. A partner who never married may not fit that list. Ask the plan administrator early.
- Health Coverage – Federal COBRA names a spouse and a dependent child as qualified beneficiaries. It does not name domestic partners. Read the plan and any state law for a partner who was never a spouse.
Count The Years For Federal Benefits
Some federal benefits turn on how long the marriage lasted. Do not pick a divorce date until you have counted.
A former spouse generally needs a marriage of 10 years before the divorce becomes final to claim on the other’s Social Security record. Couples who married in 2015 have only just reached that mark. Couples who married in 2017 have not.
For example, let’s say that a couple married in August 2017. A decree entered in June 2027 would fall short of 10 years, and a decree entered in September 2027 would not. Two more months could be worth a lot to the lower earner. It may help to raise this before anyone sets a hearing date.
Social Security also looks to state law, and it can treat certain relationships as spousal if the state gives the same inheritance rights. So a civil union or partnership may matter. The Thornton and Ely cases gave relief to survivors who were barred from marrying. Do not assume that relief reaches the divorced spouse test.
Military retirement has its own rule. Direct payment of a property share of retired pay requires 10 years of marriage overlapping 10 years of creditable service. That limit concerns direct payment by the government, so check whether your state can still divide the pay.
Confirm Legal Parentage First
Do not assume both spouses are legal parents because both raised the child. Check this before you discuss a parenting plan or child support.
A court judgment is the strongest paper. In V.L. v. E.L., the Supreme Court required Alabama to give full faith and credit to a Georgia adoption judgment. In Pavan v. Smith, the Court said Arkansas must give married same-sex couples the same birth certificate treatment as other married couples.
A birth certificate is a record, not a judgment, and the rules on parentage vary by state. Check your state’s marital presumption and how it applies to a same-sex spouse, including use of a donor. Below are some of the things to ask:
- Adoption Or Judgment – Is there an adoption decree or parentage order for each child, for each parent?
- Children Born Earlier – Was the child born before the marriage, or before a civil union? The presumption tied to marriage may not reach that child.
- Assisted Reproduction – What consents, donor agreements and clinic records exist? Check what happens to any stored embryos too.
- No Legal Tie – If one adult has no legal tie, does your state recognize a de facto parent or a similar status?
If you are a mediator or a neutral, send each client to a separate lawyer on this question. The parent without a judgment has the most to lose.
Your Next Step
At intake on your next matter, ask for the full relationship timeline and every legal document behind it. Then have a lawyer check your state’s law on premarital years and parentage before you run a single division scenario.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related:
- How does divorce change Social Security benefits?
- Which retirement plans can a QDRO not divide?
- How do you value a small business in a divorce?
- Should your client keep the house or sell it?