Whoever the settlement agreement or a court order says will pay. If neither one says anything, the answer depends on the state, and the parents may have no legal duty to pay at all.
That silence causes the trouble. The child is usually years from college when the agreement gets signed, so nobody wants to fight about it. It may still help to deal with it now, while both parents are at the table and have lawyers or a mediator to help.
Check The State First
States are far apart on this. Some let a judge order a parent to pay. Others do not treat college as part of a parent’s support duty once the child is an adult.
Below are a few examples, and they are examples only:
- Washington – A court may order postsecondary support after weighing factors such as the child’s needs and the parents’ resources and expectations. The student must stay in good academic standing and share grades with both parents. Support generally cannot cover expenses past the 23rd birthday, except in exceptional circumstances such as a disability.
- Illinois – A court can allocate college expenses under 750 ILCS 5/513, with a benchmark tied to University of Illinois costs. Check the current statute for its age and grade requirements.
- New Jersey – The leading case, Newburgh v. Arrigo, lists factors for deciding whether a parent must contribute.
- New York – A court may award educational expenses when it finds them appropriate, and the child support definition covers an unemancipated child under 21. If the parents want to pay past 21, one option is to put that in an agreement.
- Pennsylvania – The state’s Supreme Court struck down its college support statute in Curtis v. Kline, so a court order there may not be available. An agreement is what your client would rely on. Check for later law.
So where no court order is available, the agreement may be your client’s only protection.
Do Not Write "Split College 50/50"
An agreement with that sentence alone may not be enough. It reads as settled, and it leaves almost everything open.
For example, let’s say that a father earns $150,000 and a mother earns $60,000. Their agreement says they will split college equally. Eight years later their daughter picks a private school that costs $70,000 a year. The mother now owes $35,000 a year on a $60,000 income. She either breaks the agreement or goes back to court. A cap and a split tied to income would have prevented that fight.
Below are things that may be worth putting in writing:
- What Counts – List tuition, fees, books, housing, meals, travel, a laptop, a car and insurance, and say which ones are in or out.
- The Cap – Tie it to something a parent can look up, such as the in-state cost at a named public university.
- The Split – Pick a percentage or a formula based on income at the time. Say when it gets recalculated.
- The Limits – Set a number of semesters or an age limit. Say what happens with a gap year, a transfer or graduate school.
- The Student’s Part – Require full-time enrollment, a minimum grade average and shared access to grades. Say how much the student must first cover through aid, work or loans.
- The Order Of Funds – Say whether 529 money and scholarships come off the top before the parents’ split.
- The Payment Method – One option is for parents to pay the school directly when they can.
- Child Support – Say whether support stops, drops or continues while the child is away.
- The Choice Of School – Say whether both parents get a say. A parent who is left out of the decision will often argue about the bill.
Explain What The Aid Forms Will Do
The agreement does not decide who fills out the FAFSA. Federal Student Aid has its own test. For 2026-27, a student whose parents are divorced and not living together reports the parent who provided more than 50% of the student’s financial support during the last 12 months. That may not be the parent the student lives with.
Child support and alimony count for the parent who pays them. If neither parent crossed 50%, the parent with the greater income and assets is the contributor. A current spouse of that parent also reports financial information, so a remarriage can change the result.
Child support received now counts as an asset on the FAFSA, not as untaxed income.
Many private colleges also use the CSS Profile, and many of them ask for the noncustodial parent’s finances too. The College Board’s waiver form lists a decree saying a parent has no responsibility for education costs as a situation it may consider. Each college decides for itself, and some say that a parent’s refusal to take part is not enough.
So your client may see an aid offer that assumes money the other parent will never pay. It may help to tell clients this early, so that it does not come as a shock during senior year.
Do Not Assume Each Parent Can Borrow
A lot of agreements assume that Parent PLUS loans will fill the gap. That is now harder. A 2025 federal law and a May 2026 final rule set new limits for periods of enrollment beginning on or after July 1, 2026. The limits are $20,000 a year and $65,000 in total per dependent student.
Those limits are shared by all parents who borrow for that student. Two divorced parents do not each get their own $65,000. Amounts already repaid or forgiven still count against the total, and so do loans made before July 2026.
There is a limited exception for a student who was already enrolled and had received a federal loan for that program by June 30, 2026. The final rule also says Parent PLUS borrowers are no longer eligible to enroll in income-driven repayment plans. Check how this applies to a parent with older Parent PLUS loans.
An agreement can say who gets to borrow, how much, and who repays it. Leaving it for the parents to work out later may be risky.
Match The Tax Benefits To The Money
The American opportunity credit is worth up to $2,500 per eligible student. It generally goes to the taxpayer who claims the student as a dependent. Tuition paid by someone else on the student’s behalf is treated as paid by that taxpayer. Publication 970 for 2025 returns lists income limits of $90,000 for single and head of household filers, and $180,000 for joint filers.
For example, let’s say that a father pays all the tuition but the mother claims the child. The credit goes to the mother if she is under the limit, even though he wrote the check. If the parent who claims the child earns too much, the credit may be lost for everyone. It may help to run those numbers before the parents settle who claims which child and for how long.
Pin Down The 529
A 529 plan belongs to its account owner, and the owner has real control. The owner can change the beneficiary to another family member with no income tax. The owner may also be able to take the money out.
If a distribution goes directly to the student or the school, the student is treated as the recipient. If it goes anywhere else, the account owner is. Earnings on a distribution not used for qualified costs are generally taxed, usually with a 10% additional tax. The same expenses also cannot support both a tax-free 529 distribution and an education credit.
Below are things that may be worth addressing:
- Ownership – Say who owns each account after the divorce, and confirm how the plan handles a change of owner. Plan rules differ.
- Use – Say that the money is for this child’s education and that the beneficiary will not change without written consent.
- Statements – Give the other parent access to statements, at least once a year.
Start With The Agreement In Front Of You
Pull the college paragraph from your open matter and read it as if the child were enrolling next fall. Then ask whether the parents could tell what they owe, on what date, and to whom. If they could not, fix it now.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related:
- How do you protect a client’s credit during a divorce?
- What did the 2017 tax law change for divorce, and what still applies?
- How do you plan a divorce with a special needs child?
- How do you work with clients who weigh money decisions differently?