There is no standard percentage, so do not use one. Estimate the rate the owner will likely pay when the money comes out, and apply it only when you are trading pretax dollars for after-tax dollars. If both spouses are splitting the same pretax account, you may not need a discount at all.

A flat 25% or 30% is easy to say in a meeting. It can also move real money from one spouse to the other, with nothing behind it. One option is to show the rate, where it came from and how the result changes if it is wrong.

Ask Whether You Need One

Start by looking at what is being traded. A discount only matters when the two sides of a trade are taxed differently.

Below are the common situations:

  • Same Account, Split Evenly – A 50/50 split of a 401(k) gives each spouse pretax dollars. Skip the discount, unless their future tax rates will be far apart.
  • Pretax Against Cash Or Home Equity – One spouse keeps the 401(k) and the other keeps the cash or the house equity. This is where a discount belongs in the discussion.
  • Pretax Against Roth – A qualified Roth IRA distribution is not taxed. A Roth dollar and a traditional dollar are not equal, so do not add them up as if they were.
  • Pretax Against A Brokerage Account – The brokerage account has its own tax built in, because the basis generally carries over in a divorce transfer. Discount both sides, each at its own rate.

Check What Your State Allows

Courts do not all treat this the same way, and it can differ from what parties may agree to in mediation. Below are three examples:

  • New Hampshire – In Telgener, the Supreme Court said potential taxes count in valuing marital assets only if the distribution requires a taxable event, or one is certain to occur shortly after. The court would not reduce retirement funds for possible early-withdrawal penalties when withdrawal depended on the husband’s own later choices.
  • Minnesota – In Maurer v. Maurer, the Supreme Court gave trial courts discretion to consider future taxes when there is a reasonable and supportable basis for estimating the liability. Expert testimony supported the 35% rate in that case. One justice concurred separately and said taxes generally should not be considered when doing so is speculative.
  • New York – The statute lists the tax consequences to each party among the factors in equitable distribution.

These are examples only, so check your own state before you argue a number. If you may end up in front of a judge, have evidence for your rate. In a settlement, the parties have more room to agree on one.

Build The Rate From The Client’s Life

Today’s top bracket is usually the wrong number. A surgeon in the 35% bracket may not be in that bracket once the paychecks stop. Use the income the owner will likely have in the years the withdrawals happen.

Below are things that may be worth looking at:

  • Filing Status – Most clients will file as single or head of household after the divorce. Those brackets are narrower than the joint brackets they are used to.
  • Other Income – A pension, rental income, support received and earnings all stack up before the withdrawals. Withdrawals sit on top of them.
  • Social Security – Part of it may become taxable once other income passes the base amount for the filing status. So a withdrawal can raise the tax on Social Security as well.
  • Age – Under 59½, a withdrawal may carry a 10% additional tax. At 65 and up, a taxpayer may get an extra $6,000 deduction for 2025 through 2028, and that phases out starting at $75,000 of modified adjusted gross income for a single filer.
  • State – State income tax varies a lot. A move can matter, because a state generally cannot tax the retirement income of someone who no longer lives there.

Federal rates may change before your client ever withdraws a dollar. A rate is an estimate, and you should call it that in your notes and your report.

Run The Numbers

For example, let’s say that your client will be a single retiree under 65 who takes $76,100 a year from a 401(k), with no other income. In 2026, the standard deduction is $16,100, so taxable income is $60,000. The federal tax is $7,912.

That is about 10% of the withdrawal. The last dollar, however, is taxed at 22%. The first rate is the average rate and the second is the marginal rate. Which one fits depends on the account. If this account is the client’s main income, the average rate may be the better fit. If it comes on top of a pension, the marginal rate may be the better fit.

Now let’s say that one spouse keeps a $200,000 401(k) and the other keeps $200,000 in cash.

Below is what different rates do to that trade:

  • At 15% – The 401(k) counts as $170,000.
  • At 22% – The 401(k) counts as $156,000.
  • At 30% – The 401(k) counts as $140,000.

The gap between 15% and 30% is $30,000 of value. On an equal division, that changes the equalizing payment by $15,000. That is a lot to hang on a number nobody explained.

Do Not Discount Twice For Time

People sometimes reduce the account for tax and then reduce it again because the tax is years away. Be careful with that. When the rate stays the same and the growth is the same, the time cancels out.

For example, let’s say $100 in a 401(k) doubles to $200 and is taxed at 20%. That leaves $160. If you take the 20% discount today, you have $80, and if it doubles tax-free you also have $160.

That math compares pretax dollars to dollars that grow without tax, like Roth money. Cash in a taxable account pays tax on its growth along the way, so the 401(k) may deserve a smaller discount against that cash. Ask a tax professional or a financial neutral to run it when the amounts are large.

Watch For The Exceptions

Below are the situations that change the answer:

  • Roth Accounts – A qualified distribution is tax-free. A distribution generally has to come after age 59½ and after the five-year period. So check both before calling any Roth account tax-free.
  • After-Tax Basis – Some IRAs and plans hold after-tax money. Ask for Form 8606 for IRAs and the plan’s records for employer accounts. Otherwise you will discount money that was already taxed.
  • Cash Needed Now – Taxes stop being speculative if the settlement requires a withdrawal. A QDRO payment from a qualified plan to a former spouse avoids the 10% additional tax, but income tax still applies. The plan generally withholds 20% unless it is a direct rollover, and that may not match the tax actually owed.
  • Rolling Over First – The QDRO exception does not apply to IRAs. If your client needs cash and is under 59½, do not roll the whole payment to an IRA first and then withdraw.
  • Different Rates – If one spouse will be in a much lower bracket, the same dollars are worth more in that spouse’s hands. It may make sense to give that spouse more of the pretax money.

Write Down Your Reasoning

One option is to show the result at three rates, not one, and say which rate you would use and why. List the income, filing status, age and state behind each rate. If the parties agree on a rate, put it in the file with their reasons.

A client who can follow the reasoning has less cause to question it later, or to question the hours that went into it.

Your next step is to pull the last two years of returns, any Form 8606 and each account’s type. Then ask your client what income they expect in retirement, and run the three rates from there.

See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.

Related:

Bring VennBoard into your practice.

One workspace for cases, clients, and the professionals you work alongside — built for divorce professionals — including divorce financial coaches, mediators, attorneys, and adjacent practitioners.