Sort each award into marital and separate under your state’s rule, then split the net amount when it actually pays. This is one common option for unvested RSUs. A buyout is the main exception, and it only works when both spouses understand the risk they are pricing.

These awards scare a lot of clients because the paperwork is long and the numbers keep moving. The work is mostly careful reading. Most of the mistakes come from guessing at what the documents say.

Get The Papers First

Do not work from a total on a brokerage screen. It may show shares that can still be lost, and it will not tell you why they were granted.

Below are some things that are often requested:

  • Grant Agreements – Get one for every award, along with the plan document. These show the vesting dates and the forfeiture terms, and whether the award can be transferred at all.
  • Vesting Confirmations – These show the shares released, the value that day and the shares sold to cover tax.
  • Year-End Paystubs And W-2s – Compare them to the vesting confirmations. Income that shows up on one and not the other needs an explanation.
  • Bonus Plan And Offer Letter – These show what the bonus rewards and when it counts as earned.
  • Employer Letters – A letter announcing a grant may say whether it rewards past work or is meant to keep the employee. That can matter a lot in some states.

Sort Marital From Separate

There is no national rule. Each state decides what counts as marital, and the end date can differ too. In some states it is the date of separation or filing. In Delaware, the Supreme Court said the date of divorce controls.

Below are three examples of how differently states approach this:

  • New York – In DeJesus v. DeJesus, the Court of Appeals held that unvested restricted stock and options granted during the marriage can be marital property. The trial court first decides how much rewarded past work and how much is an incentive for future work, then applies a time rule to each part.
  • Illinois – The statute presumes that stock options and restricted stock granted during the marriage are marital. The court looks at the circumstances of the grant, including vesting and whether it rewards past, present or future efforts. Check the current statute.
  • California – The Hug and Nelson decisions used time rules for stock options. Hug starts the clock at the date of hire and Nelson starts it at the date of grant.

For example, let’s say that your client’s spouse received 400 RSUs in January 2024. They all vest in January 2028. The marital period ended in January 2026, so two of the four vesting years fall inside it. Under a grant-date time rule, 200 RSUs are marital. A 50/50 split gives your client 100.

Real grants often vest in stages. Run the math for each vesting date, because the marital share changes each time.

Choose How To Divide Them

Below are the usual options:

  • Split At Vesting – The employee spouse keeps the award and pays over your client’s share of the net amount at each vest. Nobody has to guess the future stock price, and both spouses carry the forfeiture risk.
  • Buy Out Now – One spouse gets other assets in exchange. This gives a clean break, but you have to price the stock, the tax and the chance the shares never vest.
  • Transfer Under The Plan – Some plans may allow this. Read the plan first and do not assume it does.

The split at vesting is one common option for unvested awards. It is slower, and the two spouses stay tied together for a few years. A buyout needs a discount, and that discount is usually the part nobody can explain later.

Do The Tax Math

RSU income is generally taxed as wages when the shares are delivered, and that usually happens at vesting. IRS Chief Counsel treated RSU income as wages in a 2023 memo, though on different facts and with no precedential weight.

Do not assume the income can be shifted to your client’s name. Rev. Rul. 2002-22 says a former spouse is taxed when exercising vested nonstatutory options or receiving vested deferred compensation that was transferred in a divorce. The ruling expressly does not apply to rights that are unvested at transfer. It also does not mention RSUs by name. So the agreement needs to say who reports the income, and a tax professional should sign off on it.

If a transfer does fall under that ruling, Rev. Rul. 2004-60 keeps FICA on the employee’s Form W-2. Income tax goes to the former spouse on a Form 1099.

Withholding is the other trap. Employers can use a flat 22% on supplemental wages, and the rate is 37% on amounts over $1 million in a year. The 22% rate is only a deposit. It may be far from what the employee actually owes.

For example, let’s say that 100 shares vest at $100 each, so $10,000 of income. The employer withholds $2,200 for income tax. If the employee’s actual rate is 35%, the income tax is $3,500. That leaves $1,300 to pay in April. An agreement that splits the shares "net of withholding" leaves that bill with the employee spouse alone.

Shares that have already vested are simpler. A transfer between spouses incident to divorce generally triggers no gain, and the receiving spouse keeps the old basis. Ask for the basis of each lot. A $50,000 lot with a low basis is worth less to your client than a $50,000 lot with a high one.

Ask What The Bonus Paid For

Treat a bonus the same way, and start with the work it paid for. The date the check arrived does not settle the question.

For example, let’s say that a $30,000 bonus for calendar 2025 is paid in March 2026, and the marital period ended on June 30, 2025. If your state looks at when the bonus was earned, half of it may be marital. That is $15,000 before tax, and $7,500 to your client on an even split.

Do not prorate every bonus by habit. In King v. Howard, the Delaware Supreme Court reversed a trial court that treated a transaction bonus as a retention bonus and counted only one-third as marital. The court held the entire bonus was earned at the closing, during the marriage, even though it could have been forfeited later.

Do Not Count It Twice

The same bonus can show up as an asset in the property division and as income for support. Some courts have been asked to treat that as double counting, and the answer depends on the state and the facts.

One option is to keep a schedule that lists each award and says whether it went into the property column, the support column, or both. If it is in both, explain why in writing. Clients tend to question a bill when they cannot follow the numbers behind it.

Write It Down Clearly

Below are things that may belong in the agreement:

  • Each Award – List it by grant date and number. Say what happens to refresher grants and replacement awards.
  • The Formula – State the fraction, the end date and how each vesting date is treated.
  • The Tax Method – Name the rate or the method, and add a true-up once the return is filed.
  • Notice And Records – Require notice and statements within a set number of days after each vest.
  • Change Events – Cover a job loss, a merger, a move and the death of either spouse.
  • Payment Timing – Say how many days the employee spouse has to pay over the net amount.

Your next step is simple. Ask for every grant agreement and three years of vesting confirmations before anyone puts a number on these awards.

See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.

Related:

Bring VennBoard into your practice.

One workspace for cases, clients, and the professionals you work alongside — built for divorce professionals — including divorce financial coaches, mediators, attorneys, and adjacent practitioners.