Check the unfinished paperwork first, work out what kind of stuck it is, and give your client one small next step. If it looks like more than you are trained to handle, refer them.
The decree is signed, and your client still cannot move. That is hard, and it does not mean something is wrong with them. Unless you are a licensed clinician, your job here is practical. You are not treating anyone.
Finish The Paperwork First
This may be a useful place to start, even if your client wants to talk about something else. Some people are stuck because the divorce really is not finished. Open items also carry real risk.
Below are some of the things to check:
- QDRO – Was the order actually drafted, approved by the plan and put in place? A decree alone may not do it. Federal guidance says a later order does not fail just because it came after the divorce, but waiting may carry risk.
- Retirement Beneficiaries – Pull the form for every employer plan. The Supreme Court has held that an ERISA plan was right to pay the ex-spouse named on the form, even though she had waived the benefit in the decree. It has also held that ERISA overrides a state law revoking an ex-spouse’s designation on a plan.
- Life Insurance – Some states revoke an ex-spouse’s designation automatically on divorce, and Minnesota’s law was upheld in 2018. Other states differ, and employer plans can follow different rules, so have your client change the form.
- The House – Is the loan still in both names? If the decree calls for a refinance, find out whether it happened. Check the deed too.
For example, let’s say that your client’s decree gave her half of a $300,000 401(k). If nobody finished the order, that money is still sitting in his plan. She may feel stuck because she cannot plan around money she does not have. That is a paperwork problem, and you can help fix it.
Find Out What Kind Of Stuck It Is
If the paperwork is done, sort out what is actually going on. This is one way of sorting it. It is a practical shortcut and it is not a diagnosis.
Below are four kinds to look for:
- Replaying – Your client keeps going back over the same events, looking for an explanation.
- Lost Role – Your client does not know who they are now that "spouse" is not the answer.
- Cannot Decide – Your client knows what needs deciding, but every choice feels too big.
- Something Gained – Staying in the divorce story gives them something, such as contact with the ex or a reason to avoid another decision.
Below are some questions that may help:
- Quiet Time – "What does an hour alone usually look like for you?"
- Finish Line – "What would have to happen for you to feel done with this?"
- The Other Side – "If the divorce was fully behind you, what would be harder?"
Listen for the pattern. Someone who says "When it stops hurting" may be dealing with a lost role. Someone who says "I need to sell the house" has a decision to break down.
If Your Client Keeps Replaying It
Do not tell your client to stop thinking about it. Research on thought suppression has found that pushed-away thoughts can come back more strongly.
One thing you can suggest is a fixed appointment for it. Your client picks a time and a place each day, and saves the replaying for that window. Researchers call this worry postponement or stimulus control, and the studies used about 30 minutes. A published trial found that it reduced worry in adults with generalized anxiety disorder, and that paper reports a review finding small to medium effects on daily worry. The same paper notes an earlier study of anxiety patients that found no effect. This research is about worry, and no research on divorce clients in particular was found for this article. So offer it as something to try, and do not promise that it works.
Do not automatically tell your client to write it all out, either. In one study of 90 recently separated or divorced people, those who brooded the most reported the least distress eight months later if they had only journaled about daily activities. The brooders assigned to write about their feelings did worse. It was a small study, and the authors stress that expressive writing helps people in other settings. Care may be needed, though, with a client who is already going in circles.
If the replaying takes over their work or their sleep, refer them.
If Your Client Has Lost A Role
Researchers have found that people’s sense of who they are can change after a breakup, and that less clarity about it goes along with more distress. So "just find yourself" is not much help.
It may help to keep this small. Ask what your client did before the marriage, or during it, that had nothing to do with the marriage. Then ask for one thing that goes on the calendar this week. That could be a class or a phone call to an old friend.
If Your Client Cannot Decide
The decision is usually too big as it is written. "Figure out the house" is really several decisions.
For example, let’s say that your client has been saying for a year that she needs to deal with the house. Below is one way to break it up:
- Get The Payoff – Ask for the current mortgage payoff figure. Nothing is decided by asking.
- Get A Value – Ask a local agent or an appraiser what the house might sell for.
- Talk To A Lender – Find out what she would qualify for on her own income.
- Then Choose – Make the real decision only after those three answers are in.
The first three steps commit her to nothing. Put one on the calendar before she leaves your office.
If Being Stuck Is Giving Them Something
People can get something out of a hard stretch without meaning to. It might be contact with the ex through arguments, attention from friends, or a reason to put off a job change.
Do not accuse your client of anything. A professional might say something like this. "Most people have something that’s hard to give up, even in a bad situation. What might be different for you if this was over?" Then be quiet and let them answer.
If you bill by the hour, watch this one closely. If a client keeps calling to go over the same ground, those are the hours they may later question. Tell them kindly what you can help with and what you cannot, and give them the name of someone who can help with the rest.
Know When To Refer
Below are signs that may be a reason to refer to a licensed mental health professional:
- Daily Life – They cannot keep up with work or basic daily tasks.
- Low Mood – They seem deeply low, and it is not lifting.
- Drinking Or Drugs – Their use has gone up since the divorce.
- Self-Harm – They mention hurting themselves or not wanting to be alive.
If your client talks about self-harm, do not wait for the next appointment. The 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is free and open all day, every day, by call, text or chat. If there is immediate danger, call 911.
If you are a coach, ICF’s code asks you to work within your competency, and to consider a different professional or resource when coaching is no longer helping. Lawyers and financial professionals should do the same.
It may help to find one or two therapists who see divorced clients now, before you need them.
Pick One Client This Week
Think of the client who has been on your mind. Before your next conversation, pull their decree and check the QDRO, the beneficiary forms and the house loan. Then ask them the finish line question, and agree on one small step before they hang up.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related:
- How do you help a client who avoids looking at money?
- When should a divorce team include a coach?
- Should your client keep the house or sell it?
- Which retirement plans can a QDRO not divide?