Very little of the law is different. The mistakes cost more, because the assets are harder to see, harder to value and taxed in different ways.
No special set of divorce rules starts at a certain net worth. Your state’s property and support rules still apply. What changes is the amount of work behind each number on the balance sheet.
A wealthy client can still be scared, and may have no idea what the family owns. Be patient about that, then get the documents.
Compare After-Tax Numbers
Do not divide a large estate on face value. Transfers between spouses, or between former spouses incident to the divorce, are generally tax free under federal law. The person who receives the asset also takes the old tax basis. That means the tax does not go away. It moves to whoever keeps the asset.
For example, let’s say that one spouse takes $1,000,000 in cash. The other takes $1,000,000 in stock with a basis of $200,000. If the stock is sold, there is $800,000 of gain. At the top federal rates of 20 percent plus the 3.8 percent net investment income tax, that is about $190,000 in tax, before any state tax.
Those two piles are not equal, and your client will find out when the tax bill comes. One option is to put a basis column on every balance sheet before anyone discusses percentages.
Below are some other tax items to check:
- Loss Carryovers – Capital loss carryovers from a joint return are divided by which spouse had the losses. They do not simply split in half, so ask whose losses they are.
- Nonresident Spouses – The tax-free transfer rule does not apply if the receiving spouse is a nonresident alien. Check citizenship and residency before you agree to any transfer.
- Alimony – For divorce instruments signed after 2018, alimony is not deductible by the payer and not income to the recipient. Older instruments can follow the old rules, so read the date and any later changes.
Read The Deal Documents
Do not rely on a statement that shows one value for equity pay or a business. Read the plan, the grant letters, the operating agreement and the buy-sell agreement. Those papers tell you what can be transferred, what can be sold and when.
Nonqualified stock options and nonqualified deferred compensation can have a clean tax result. An IRS ruling says the transferring spouse is not taxed on a transfer incident to divorce, and the former spouse is taxed when the options are exercised or the compensation is paid. That does not mean the plan allows a transfer. It may help to ask for the plan’s rules first.
A closely held company raises two more questions:
- Goodwill – States treat personal and business goodwill differently. Check your state’s rule before you hire a valuation expert, and make sure the expert knows it too.
- Redemptions – If the company buys out one spouse’s shares, a federal regulation decides who is taxed on that redemption. The spouses can choose the result in the divorce instrument or a written agreement, but the language must be express and the timing rules are strict. Do not leave this to the closing documents.
Follow The Trusts
Get every trust instrument, not a summary. Whether a beneficial interest counts in the divorce depends on state law and the trust’s terms.
Massachusetts is a good example of how fine that line can be. In Pfannenstiehl v. Pfannenstiehl, its highest court held that one spouse’s interest in a discretionary trust was too speculative to count in the marital estate. Later Massachusetts decisions have looked at other trust terms and reached different results. Do not carry that result into another state, or even another trust, without checking.
Trusts created during the marriage raise a tax question too. A former rule in Section 682 of the tax code moved trust income tax to the former spouse who received it. That rule was repealed for divorce instruments signed after 2018. As a result, the grantor of a grantor trust may keep paying tax on income that goes to the former spouse. It may help to have a tax professional read any such trust before the settlement is signed.
Look At Gift And Estate Tax
Estate planning done during the marriage does not undo itself. Federal law treats transfers under a written settlement as made for full value if the divorce happens within a set window. That window starts one year before the agreement is signed and ends two years after. Watch this date if the divorce may be delayed.
The federal basic exclusion amount is $15,000,000 for 2026, so many clients will not owe gift tax. Your wealthiest clients may have already used much of theirs. Ask for past gift tax returns.
Below are some of the things to review:
- Earlier Gifts – Find out which assets left the marital balance sheet through gifts or trusts. Ask who is still a beneficiary of each trust.
- Retirement Plans – The federal plan rules can override a state law that revokes a former spouse’s designation on divorce. The Supreme Court said so in Egelhoff v. Egelhoff. Change the forms once the plan and the decree allow it.
- Life Insurance – The Supreme Court upheld Minnesota’s revocation-on-divorce law for a life insurance policy in Sveen v. Melin. Other states have different laws, and that case did not involve an employer plan. Do not depend on any of these laws. Fill out the form.
Look Hard At Liquidity
A large estate on paper may not have much cash. Your client could be awarded a large share of a company and still struggle to pay the mortgage. If one spouse buys out the other over time, options to request include collateral, life insurance and a clear default remedy. An unsecured promise from a former spouse is a poor retirement plan.
Do not assume that child support follows a simple formula. Check whether your state’s schedule has an income ceiling, and what your state’s law says about support above it.
Check Old Tax Returns
A joint return makes each spouse liable for the whole tax. A complicated business return can leave your client on the hook for years after the divorce. Federal law offers innocent spouse relief and other relief, but it has conditions and deadlines, and your client should not count on it.
One option is to ask for a written tax indemnity, with security if the other spouse has been controlling the returns. Check foreign accounts as well. A U.S. person whose foreign accounts total more than $10,000 at any time in a year generally must file an FBAR. Ask for those filings along with the tax returns.
Your Next Step
Open your current matter and pick the three largest assets. Write down the basis, the transfer limits and who pays the tax if each asset is sold next year. If you cannot fill in those boxes, you know which documents to ask for next.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related:
- How do you value a small business in a divorce?
- How do you divide RSUs and bonuses in a divorce?
- What happens to a grantor trust after a divorce?
- How do you find hidden assets and income in a divorce?
- When does a divorce case need a lifestyle analysis?