Whoever the contracts say pays. The seller, the listing broker or the buyer can pay the buyer’s broker, and the settlement did not set a rate or move the bill to one side.
So in a divorce, do not assume the old custom will decide it. Your settlement agreement should say who decides and how the cost comes out of the proceeds.
Know What Changed
The National Association of Realtors settled the home seller commission claims in 2024, and the practice changes began on August 17, 2024. The trial court gave final approval that November. The Eighth Circuit affirmed on August 19, 2026, and issued its mandate on October 2, 2026.
Below are the main changes:
- No Offers On The MLS – A listing can no longer show an offer of compensation to buyer brokers on a Realtor MLS. An offer can still be communicated off the MLS.
- Written Buyer Agreements – MLS participants working with a buyer must have a written agreement before touring a home. It has to spell out how the buyer’s agent is paid. State law may require one sooner.
- Seller Disclosure – The listing agent must disclose any payment to a buyer’s agent in writing, with the amount or rate, and get the seller’s approval first.
Know What Did Not Change
Your client still signs a listing agreement and usually pays the listing broker from that contract. Commissions were not set by law before the settlement, and they are not set by law now. Each one is negotiated.
A seller can still choose to pay something toward the buyer’s agent. A seller can also advertise concessions on the MLS, such as help with buyer closing costs. A buyer can ask for it in an offer, so your client may get that request even if the listing is silent.
State law can add to this. Washington, for example, has a statute that says a firm may be paid by the seller, the buyer, a third party, or through sharing between firms. It also requires a services agreement before a firm can be paid by any party. Check your own state’s brokerage rules and commission rules.
Watch The Buyer’s Loan
The buyer’s financing can change what your client gets asked for.
Below are points that may be useful to know before reviewing an offer:
- FHA – HUD said in 2024 that reasonable seller-paid buyer agent fees, paid under local law or custom, would not be treated as interested party contributions under its policy.
- Fannie Mae – The current Fannie Mae guide says fees a seller typically pays under local custom fall outside those limits.
- Financing The Fee – As of 2024, NAR reported that FHA, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would not let a buyer roll the commission into the mortgage. Check the current agency guides.
- VA – VA Circular 26-24-14 lets a veteran pay reasonable and customary buyer-broker charges under a temporary variance. It also says seller-paid charges are not a concession. Check that the circular is still in effect.
A buyer who is short on cash may ask your client to pay. A buyer may also offer more for the house and then ask for a credit. Look at the net number, because the price alone can mislead you.
Run The Net For Both Spouses
The split of the commission depends on the wording of the agreement. It may help to run it before anyone signs.
For example, let’s say that a house sells for $500,000 with a $300,000 mortgage. The listing broker charges 2.5 percent, which is $12,500. The buyer asks for another 2.5 percent toward their agent, and other closing costs are $5,000. The net is $170,000.
If the agreement splits net proceeds evenly, each spouse gets $85,000. They share the buyer’s request equally, so they have similar reasons to deal with it.
Now let’s say that the agreement gives one spouse $100,000 off the top, and the other spouse gets the rest. The first spouse gets $100,000 and the other gets $70,000. Every dollar of commission falls on one person, and the spouse with the fixed amount may not care what gets conceded. One option is to draft around that.
The same issue comes up in a buyout. Some agreements take a percentage off the house value for sale costs even though nobody is selling. States may treat speculative sale costs differently, so check yours. If the spouses agree to a deduction, do not use an old 6 percent habit. Get a current quote, or have them decide knowingly that they are using a compromise.
Put It In The Agreement
Do not leave this for the listing appointment. Two spouses who are not speaking may not settle it in the agent’s office.
Below are things that may be worth writing down:
- Who Picks The Broker – Name the broker, or give each spouse a turn at naming three and let the other pick.
- Listing Commission – State a maximum rate, or who may agree to a rate.
- Buyer-Side Payment – Say whether the seller will offer anything to a buyer’s agent, and the most either spouse can approve without the other. Since the seller’s approval is required in writing, say who signs it.
- Concessions – Give a dollar or percentage limit for closing cost credits and repair credits.
- Price Decisions – Set the list price process, the date for each price reduction, and the lowest offer they must accept.
- Tie-Breaker – Name a mediator or neutral for a quick decision. A short clause here can spare your client hours of letters they will question on the bill.
- Proceeds – Say how closing costs come out before the split, and whether the money stays in escrow until any disputes are resolved.
Check who has to sign. In California, both spouses must join in selling community real property. Other states have their own title, homestead and community property rules. Some also have orders limiting property sales while a divorce is pending. It may help to read the deed and your local rules before the listing goes up.
Mention The Tax And The Next House
Commissions reduce the amount realized on a sale. IRS Publication 523 lists sales commissions among selling expenses, along with legal fees and advertising. That lowers the gain figured for the home sale exclusion. Ask a tax professional how a seller-paid buyer broker fee or a buyer credit is treated.
Your client may also be a buyer soon. If your client buys the next home, they will sign their own written agreement before touring. The fee may fall to them if the seller will not pay it. Put a line for that in the post-divorce budget, and make sure they understand the agreement before they sign it. Free or low-cost help may be available through a HUD-approved housing counselor.
Get Quotes Now
If a sale is likely, have your client get two written listing quotes this week. Ask each broker for an estimated net sheet with and without a buyer-side payment. Then draft the clause from those numbers.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related:
- Should your client keep the house or sell it?
- How do you protect a client’s credit during a divorce?
- What should you ask for in divorce discovery?