Make the task small. Ask for one number, from one document, by one date. Then sit with them while they look at it, and do not let them sign anything they have not read.

This is common, and it does not make your client foolish or lazy. It does cost them money, and it can cost you too, in unanswered requests and in hours they later refuse to pay for.

You do not need to work out why they avoid it. You need the documents, and you need your client to understand them well enough to decide.

Know What The Research Says

People avoid information they expect to be bad, even when it is free and useful. Golman, Hagmann and Loewenstein reviewed this research in 2017 and called it common.

Money has its own version. Karlsson, Loewenstein and Seppi found that investors checked their accounts less when markets were falling or flat. A later study of 401(k) investors by Sicherman and colleagues found fewer logins after bad market days, and people who did this in one year tended to do it the next. Investors with larger holdings were more likely to avoid the information, so having more money did not cure it.

There is a limit here. Gherzi and colleagues studied active online investors and found that they checked more after both up days and down days. So this does not happen to everyone. None of these studies looked at people going through a divorce, either.

Shapiro and Burchell found that financial anxiety could be measured as its own thing, separate from general anxiety and depression, and that people scoring high tended to look away from financial information in lab tasks.

Avoiding a statement is an ordinary thing people do when they expect bad news. So do not treat it as a character flaw, and do not treat it as a reason to wait.

Figure Out What You Are Looking At

Avoidance can have very different causes. Before you pick an approach, ask which of these fits.

Below are the usual possibilities:

  • Never Did It – The other spouse handled everything, and your client does not know where to start. This is a skills problem, and you can help with it directly.
  • Afraid Of The Number – Your client knows roughly what is there and does not want to see it. Small steps usually help most here.
  • Kept Out – Your client may have been denied access. That can be part of coercive control, and it changes what you should do. See the section on stopping below.
  • Hiding Something – A client who "cannot find" statements may know what they show. Tell them plainly what incomplete disclosure could mean for them, and tell them what you cannot do.
  • Cannot Do It Right Now – Your client may be in crisis, or may have trouble understanding the material at all. That is a different conversation.

Make It Small

For example, let’s say that your client has not opened a 401(k) statement in three years. Her husband handled everything. Her financial affidavit is due in 30 days, and your last two emails asking for "all financial documents" got no answer.

Do not send a third email like that. A list of 40 items is exactly what she is avoiding.

Below are other options:

  • One Item – Ask only for the most recent 401(k) statement this week. Next week, ask for one more.
  • One Number – Ask her to find the balance and tell you that one number. She does not need to understand the rest yet.
  • Sit Together – Book 20 minutes, in person or on a screen, and open the first statement with her. Show her where the balance is and what the other lines mean.
  • Get Read Access – Help her log in herself or request statements in her own name, if she has the right to do so. Then she does not have to rely on anyone else for them.
  • Run The Free Check – Have her pull her credit reports at AnnualCreditReport.com. It costs nothing, and it shows debts she may not know about.
  • Write It Down – After each step, send two lines saying what you received and what comes next. Keep one item open at a time.

Start with the thing that is easiest to find and least scary. A paycheck stub is usually easier than a credit card statement.

Set dates that are real. If a deadline is coming, tell her what it is and what happens if it is missed. Disclosure rules vary a lot by state. California, for example, requires each party to serve a preliminary declaration of disclosure under penalty of perjury. Do not let kindness turn into a missed deadline. A sworn form she has not read is a real problem for her.

Do Not Do It For Them

It is tempting to take over. Doing that for long may not be wise.

The decisions belong to the client. Model Rule 1.2(a) leaves the choice to settle with the client, and Rule 1.4(b) asks the lawyer to explain things well enough for an informed decision. Your state’s version controls. The 2025 Model Standards for Family and Divorce Mediation tell mediators to structure the process so that parties have enough information to decide. A client who agreed without looking may come back later and say they did not understand. They may be right.

So do not treat a signature as understanding. Ask your client to tell you in their own words what they are getting, what they are giving up, and what it means month to month. If they cannot, slow down.

Keep a short record of what you explained and when. For a financial advisor or neutral, that means showing your assumptions. For a lawyer, it may mean a letter. It helps your client, and it answers the question when they ask later what all those hours were for.

Know When To Stop

Below are times when it may help to stop trying to fix this alone:

  • A Clinical Concern – If your client seems unable to function, or you are worried about their safety, recommend a licensed mental health professional. Do not try to treat it yourself. If they want help with the process and nothing clinical is going on, a divorce coach may be enough.
  • Trouble Understanding – For lawyers, check your state’s version of Model Rule 1.14 on clients with limited capacity. Mediators have the barriers standard, which says not to go ahead if a party is unable to participate meaningfully.
  • Signs Of Control – Talk to the client alone. Mediators are called on to screen separately and confidentially for abuse, including coercive control. Bring in people trained for it.
  • Information Being Withheld – The 2025 Model Standards list a party withholding information needed for informed decision-making as a reason a mediator may suspend or end the mediation. In collaborative practice, the IACP standards call on professionals to counsel a client whose conduct undermines the process. Lawyers should check what their state’s rules require.

No one in this list should be giving therapy as part of the financial work. The mediation standards say so directly for mediators. The same rule can apply to everyone else on the team.

Send One Request

Look at your open matters for the client who has gone quiet on documents. Send one short message today asking for one statement and offering 20 minutes to open it together. Put the date in the message. Then ask for the next one.

See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.

Related:

Bring VennBoard into your practice.

One workspace for cases, clients, and the professionals you work alongside — built for divorce professionals — including divorce financial coaches, mediators, attorneys, and adjacent practitioners.