A sale may fit better unless your client can refinance alone and still afford the house after support ends. Some clients can do that. Others may find out they cannot only after they have traded other assets to get it.

This house may be where the kids grew up, and that matters. Run the numbers anyway, before your client agrees to anything.

Find Out If They Can Qualify

Start with a lender, not with the settlement draft. A promise to refinance is worth little if no lender will make the loan.

Below are some of the rules to check on a loan sold to Fannie Mae. Other loan programs have their own rules, so ask a lender early.

  • Buyout Refinance – Buying out a co-owner in a divorce settlement can count as a limited cash-out refinance if the home was jointly owned for at least 12 months. All parties must sign a written agreement on the transfer and on where the money goes.
  • No Cash To The Keeper – The spouse who ends up with the house cannot take any of the proceeds. So this loan will not also pay for a new roof.
  • Support As Income – The lender needs six months of documented full, regular and timely payments. The support must also be expected to last at least three years from the application date.
  • Lump Sums – An equalization payment does not count as steady income.

The six-month rule can be a real problem. Your client may need the refinance right when the support has only just started. Ask the lender about timing before you write a refinance deadline into the agreement.

Price The New Payment

Your client may be picturing the old payment. The refinance usually replaces it, and the rate can change too.

For example, let’s say that the house is worth $600,000 with a $200,000 mortgage at 3 percent. Your client owes the other spouse $200,000 for half the equity. The new loan is $400,000 at a made-up rate of 6.5 percent. The principal and interest go from about $850 a month to about $2,500.

Then add the costs that do not show up on a loan estimate.

Below are some of the costs to include:

  • Taxes And Insurance – Use the current bills, and check for any tax break tied to the old household.
  • Repairs – Budget for the roof and the furnace, because there is now one paycheck to cover them.
  • Support End Dates – Check the budget for the year support stops and the year the youngest child ages out.
  • Retirement Savings – Keep a line for retirement. If the budget only balances with no saving, the house costs too much.

Do Not Leave Both Names On The Loan

The decree can say that one spouse pays the mortgage. The lender is not bound by that, because the original contract is still in place. If the payments stop, the spouse who moved out can still take a hit on their credit.

Federal law helps with one part of this. A lender generally cannot use a due-on-sale clause because of a transfer under a divorce decree or a related property settlement, on a home with fewer than five units. So a deed alone should not trigger the clause. Under the servicing rules, the spouse who gets the house can also become a confirmed successor in interest once the servicer confirms identity and ownership.

That does not take the other spouse off the note. It also has a cost for the spouse who moved out. Fannie Mae lets a lender leave out a debt that a court assigned to someone else, but the borrower’s payment history before the assignment still counts. A home on which the borrower is still obligated can also count as a financed property.

One option is to write in a refinance deadline. If your client has not refinanced by that date, the house goes on the market. Name the date, the listing process and who pays for what. Some loans may also allow an assumption and a release, so ask the servicer.

Count The Tax Before Picking A Number

A married couple and a single owner do not get the same tax break. So the choice to keep the house can change the tax.

A married couple filing jointly can exclude up to $500,000 of gain, if either one meets the ownership test and both meet the use test. A single person can generally exclude up to $250,000.

For example, let’s say that a couple bought a house for $300,000, and it is now worth $900,000. Ignore selling costs and improvements to keep it simple. The gain is $600,000.

If they sell while still married and file jointly, up to $500,000 can be excluded, and $100,000 is taxable. If one spouse keeps it and sells after the divorce, the exclusion is $250,000, and $350,000 is taxable.

That is the same house with very different taxes. A transfer between spouses has no tax at that moment, but the original basis moves with it. So your client may be buying a future tax bill along with the house.

Below are some of the rules your tax professional should check:

  • Ownership Time – A spouse who receives the house can count the time the other spouse owned it.
  • Moving Out – A spouse who owns the home and moved out can count the other spouse’s use while that spouse is granted use under a divorce or separation instrument. Without that language, the out-spouse’s two-of-five-year clock keeps running.
  • Basis Records – Get the closing papers and improvement receipts now. They are harder to find later.

Be Careful With A Deferred Sale

Some couples agree to wait until the youngest child finishes school. It can work, so it remains an option. It may help to have every open item written down.

Below are some of the items to cover:

  • The Sale Trigger – Name the date and the events that force a sale, such as remarriage or a missed payment.
  • The Costs – Say who pays the mortgage, repairs and big replacements, and how those amounts are credited at sale.
  • The Tax – Put the use language in the instrument, and rerun the exclusion numbers for the expected sale date.
  • The Credit – Remember that both spouses remain tied to the loan for years.

Compare After-Tax Dollars

A dollar of house and a dollar of retirement account are different dollars. The house has future selling costs and possible tax. The retirement account has future income tax. Cash from a sale can be spent now.

Before your client trades retirement for the house, it may help to compare them after tax and after selling costs. Do the comparison for at least two outcomes, keeping the house and selling now. It may also help to run the keep option with a sale three years later, because a client who cannot carry the house may have to sell it anyway.

For a client with little money, a HUD-approved housing counselor can review the budget and the loan options, often at little or no cost. The CFPB has a search tool by ZIP code.

Get The Letter First

This week, have your client call a lender and ask for a written answer on qualifying, using the actual support figures. Then run the keep and sell numbers side by side before anyone drafts the house clause.

See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.

Related:

Bring VennBoard into your practice.

One workspace for cases, clients, and the professionals you work alongside — built for divorce professionals — including divorce financial coaches, mediators, attorneys, and adjacent practitioners.