Hire a qualified appraiser, clean up the owner’s earnings, and apply your state’s rules before anyone picks a number. Those rules can move the value more than the math does, so start there.

Your client may have spent twenty years building this company, or watching a spouse build it. Either way, the number will feel personal. Keep the work on the records.

Settle The State-Law Questions First

It may help to answer these before an appraiser starts work. A report built on the wrong assumption means paying for the work twice, and clients question those hours.

Below are the questions to answer:

  • Standard Of Value – Some states look at fair market value, which assumes a sale to a hypothetical buyer. Others look closer to fair value or value to the owner. Read your state’s cases, because the label is not always used the same way.
  • Valuation Date – States differ on whether to use the separation date, the filing date, or a date near trial. A growing company can look very different at each one.
  • Separate Property – The business may have started before the marriage. Check how your state treats growth during the marriage, including whether it matters who caused the growth.
  • Goodwill – Some states divide goodwill and some divide only part of it.
  • Discounts – Some states allow a marketability or minority discount, and others resist it.

Decide Who Does The Work

Under the AICPA valuation standard, a CPA appraiser can do a valuation engagement or a calculation engagement. A valuation engagement produces a conclusion of value. A calculation engagement uses agreed procedures, does less work, and produces a calculated value. Other appraiser credentials have their own standards, so ask which ones apply.

Start with the cheaper route when it fits. For a small shop with clean books and two cooperative spouses, a calculation or one neutral appraiser may be enough. That route may not fit when one spouse controls the records and the other does not believe them.

Revenue Ruling 59-60 is a useful checklist even though it is a tax ruling and not divorce law. It lists eight factors, including the company’s history, the industry outlook, book value, earning capacity, and comparable public stocks. If a report skips one, ask why.

Ask For The Right Records

Below are some records that are often requested first:

  • Tax Returns – Five years of business returns, K-1s and personal returns.
  • Books – The general ledger, not only the summary statements. The ledger shows each personal charge and each unusual payment.
  • Pay Records – Payroll reports, owner draws, and pay for family members on the payroll.
  • Loan Files – Applications and personal financial statements given to banks. Compare what the owner told the bank with what the owner says now.
  • Governing Documents – Operating agreements, shareholder agreements and any buy-sell agreement. A price in a buy-sell agreement may or may not control in a divorce, depending on the state.
  • Customer Records – Sales by customer and any contracts. If one customer is half the revenue, the appraiser needs to know that.

Clean Up The Earnings

The tax return shows what the owner reported. An appraiser wants to know what the business really earns.

For example, let’s say that a spouse owns a small plumbing company. The return shows $50,000 of profit, and the owner takes a $150,000 salary. The company also pays $25,000 a year for a personal truck and family phones.

A hired manager would cost $100,000. So the adjusted earnings are $50,000 of profit, plus $25,000 of personal costs, plus $50,000 of salary above the market wage. That comes to $125,000. If the appraiser used a multiple of 3, which is made up for this example, the business would be worth $375,000.

The wage assumption drives that result. Every $10,000 change in the market wage moves the value by $30,000 here. It may help to ask how the appraiser chose the wage before looking at the multiple.

Look For Double Counting

The same dollars can show up twice. The business value in the example above comes from the $125,000 of adjusted earnings. If support is then figured on the owner’s full $225,000, some of that income has already been paid out through the buyout.

States do not agree on this. In Keane v. Keane, New York’s highest court said double counting can arise with intangibles such as licenses or goodwill, or the value of a service business. It did not find double counting for an income-producing asset that exists apart from its income. Other states have their own rules, and some have no clear rule.

Do not settle property first and treat support as a separate talk later. Use the same wage assumption in both places, or be able to explain why they differ.

Sort The Goodwill

Personal goodwill is tied to the owner’s own skill and reputation. Enterprise goodwill stays with the business if the owner leaves. The split can decide most of the value in a professional practice.

States split on this. Some treat personal goodwill in a professional practice as separate property. New Jersey’s Dugan v. Dugan (1983) treated the goodwill of a law practice as divisible. Check your state’s current law.

Do not bring a rule over from another state. Ask the appraiser to show the goodwill split and the reasons for it, even if your state may not need it.

Check Discounts And Taxes

A marketability discount can take a large bite out of the value. New Jersey’s Brown v. Brown (2002) rejected marketability and minority discounts in that divorce, where no sale was planned. Other states leave more room, so check yours.

The tax side needs a tax professional. Below are some of the points to raise:

  • Transfers Between Spouses – Under section 1041, a transfer incident to divorce generally has no gain or loss. The basis carries over, so the spouse keeping the shares also keeps the future tax.
  • Company Buyouts – A redemption by the company follows its own rules under Treasury Regulation 1.1041-2. The agreement can say which spouse takes the tax, but it has to meet that regulation’s terms and timing.
  • Interest On A Buyout Note – The note principal may fall under section 1041, but interest is a separate question. Ask a tax professional how it is taxed and deducted.
  • Assumed Taxes – Appraisers differ on whether to reduce pass-through earnings for assumed taxes. Ask how the report handled it and whether your state has spoken on it.

If the owner pays over time, the other spouse is taking on the risk of the business. Options to request include a secured note, life insurance on the owner, and a clear default clause. Check the operating agreement first, because it may limit pledges of ownership interests.

Start With One Page

Before you hire anyone, write one page with your state’s answers on value standard, date, goodwill and discounts. Send it to the appraiser with the records list, and ask them to confirm the assumptions in writing.

See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.

Related:

Bring VennBoard into your practice.

One workspace for cases, clients, and the professionals you work alongside — built for divorce professionals — including divorce financial coaches, mediators, attorneys, and adjacent practitioners.