A divorce case needs a lifestyle analysis when reported income cannot explain the spending, when the books cannot be trusted, or when the marital standard of living is in dispute. If the paychecks and returns already explain the spending, do not pay for one.
Decide Which Kind You Need
The same words get used for two different jobs, and clients end up paying for the wrong one.
Below are the two jobs:
- Standard Of Living – This shows what the household actually spent during the marriage. It supports a budget for a spousal support claim.
- Income Test – This compares money coming in with money going out. It asks whether there is income that the returns do not show.
The IRS uses similar tools. Its manual describes a T-account, with sources of funds on one side and expenses on the other. Its formal indirect methods include source and application of funds, bank deposits and net worth.
Say which job you want before anyone starts. The records overlap, but the question and the conclusion are different.
Look For These Signs
Below are signs that may deserve a closer look:
- A Spending Gap – The household spends much more than reported income, and savings and debt do not explain it.
- A Cash Business – Restaurants, contractors and salons can take cash that never reaches a bank statement.
- Bad Books – The IRS manual treats missing, incomplete or irregular records as a reason to use indirect methods. The same test may be useful here.
- Standard Of Living In Dispute – California and Washington both list the marital standard of living as a support factor. Other states weigh it differently, so check yours.
- Two Sets Of Numbers – A loan application shows far more income than the tax return for the same year.
- A Sudden Drop In Income – Earnings fall just before filing, while the spending stays the same.
For example, let’s say that a couple reports $120,000 in income, and about $90,000 is left after tax. Bank and card statements show $180,000 of spending a year. Savings did not fall and no new debt appeared. That leaves a $90,000 gap. A $60,000 gift from her parents with a clear check trail would bring the question down to $30,000.
Know When To Skip It
Below are times when one may not be needed:
- The Records Already Match – In a two-paycheck household, a simple reconciliation of statements may answer everything.
- The Money Is Too Small – If the income in question would change support by a small amount, the analysis can cost more than it brings in. Some clients refuse to pay for that kind of work.
- The Gap Has An Answer – Gifts, inheritances, loans and old savings can all pay for a nice life. Ask about them first, because they are not income in the usual sense.
- All You Have Are Photos – A boat in a picture does not tell you who paid for it.
That last one has a real warning behind it. In In re Marriage of Loh, a 2001 California appellate decision, a trial court set $9,000 a month of imputed income from photos of cars and a girlfriend’s house. The appeals court reversed. It treated recent tax returns as presumptively correct, and it would not let a new partner’s money come in through the back door. Check how later California cases apply it.
The same court left the door open. It said a much more detailed showing could prove unreported income, such as tracing bank withdrawals or testimony from a forensic accountant. It also noted that the mother never moved to compel the tax returns. So finish your discovery first. Other states have their own case law, so do not take this as the general rule.
Build It From Real Records
A lifestyle analysis is only as good as its starting point. Holland v. United States, a 1954 Supreme Court case, gives a useful checklist for the net worth method. It is a criminal tax case, so it does not set a divorce standard. Even so, the opening net worth had to be established with reasonable certainty, reasonable leads had to be checked, and a likely source of taxable income had to be shown.
The IRS also has a limit of its own. Section 7602(e) says it cannot use these techniques to find unreported income without a reasonable indication that there is some. That does not bind you, but you can choose to hold your work to the same test.
Below are things that may be useful to include in the work:
- A Fixed Period – One option is 24 to 36 months before separation, with the same period shown for every account.
- Opening And Closing Balances – Include cash, accounts and debts on both dates. The change between those two dates is what you are testing.
- All Sources – List gifts, loans, inheritances, sale proceeds and account withdrawals along with income.
- Actual Spending – Use statements wherever you can. The IRS manual uses Bureau of Labor Statistics data to estimate living costs when actual numbers are missing. It may help to label any estimate of that kind clearly.
- Clean Transfers – Take out transfers between accounts, or you will count the same dollar twice.
- The New Household – Keep a new partner’s money separate. California bars using that income for child support in most cases, and other states have their own rules.
- Written Assumptions – List each assumption, so the other side and your client can test it.
Decide early who will do the work. A lawyer may need a retained expert to testify. A mediator or a neutral can run it as a joint exercise, but only if both spouses agree to supply the records.
Before the result goes in writing, talk to a tax professional. If the analysis points to unreported income on a joint return, your client may have exposure as well.
Your next step is a one-page T-account. Put sources on the left and spending on the right, using one year of returns and statements. If the two sides are close, stop there and tell your client so. If they are far apart, you now have a reason to scope the full work, and a number your client can understand before paying for it.
See what your last matter missed. Bring VennBoard one closed matter. We’ll run an accuracy audit against the final outcome. If the readout is useful, you can start a no-cost 3-month pilot on live matters. Invite three colleagues, and when they join, you get 3 more months free. Start my pilot
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state.
Related:
- What should you ask for in divorce discovery?
- How do you find hidden assets and income in a divorce?
- How do you value a small business in a divorce?